September 29, 2023
Fighting words: The First Amendment and anonymous online speech

Photo: Mark Wemple

Deborah L. Thomson is a partner at the Women's Law Group in Tampa.

Of Counsel - Florida Law

Fighting words: The First Amendment and anonymous online speech

Does the First Amendment protect anonymous online speech if it's not true?

Art Levy | 8/27/2015

There’s nothing in Deborah L. Thomson’s resume to indicate she’s the sort of attorney who goes out of her way looking for a fight.

“Our philosophy here at work, we prefer for cases to settle amicably,” says Thomson, a partner at the Women’s Law Group in Tampa. “We prefer the collaborative process, not having to go to litigation, because litigation is not a fun process. It’s a stressful process and a costly process. My nature is to resolve things.”

It might have been easier to stick to her credo and ignore the unflattering comments that someone posted about her on Avvo.com, a lawyer-review and rating website. But Thomson can’t do it. The anonymous comments, she says, were untrue and defamatory. She refuses to let them go unchallenged.

“Everybody has a right to express an opinion,” she says. “They can speak the truth, but you can’t say false things about somebody. That is not protected. Free speech is protected. Opinions are protected. But if it’s false, it’s not protected. That’s the whole basis of my following through with this because this person said that I didn’t show up for a nine-hour mediation because I have vacation days. That has never happened. It’s just untrue.”

The Sept. 24, 2013, Avvo posting, attributed only to “a divorce client,” also accused Thomson of failing to subpoena critical documents relating to a divorce case. Thomson, in response, doesn’t think that the writer of the review was actually a client of hers and that the posting is simply “a personal attack.” She thinks she knows who the poster is, but, to pursue a defamation case, she needs Avvo to hand over the anonymous poster’s name — and Avvo has so far refused.

The case, most recently heard by Washington State’s Court of Appeals, is getting national attention. Legal observers see it as a test of how far the First Amendment can go in protecting anonymous online speech. In July, the Washington court sided with Avvo, contending that Thomson did not provide the court with enough evidence to prove that defamation occurred. Consumer groups declared the decision a victory for online anonymity, and Avvo saw it as a victory, too.

“Whether they’re leaving reviews on Amazon or commenting on an op-ed in their local paper, consumers have a right to protect their anonymity online and to freely express their opinions on the products and services provided by businesses,” says Josh King, Avvo’s general counsel. “This is a developing area of the law, and this case helps set a precedent for consumers’ legal rights when expressing themselves online. At Avvo, in order for us to deliver consumers the transparency they’ve come to expect, we need to protect and provide the ability to comment on the quality and delivery of professional services without fear of a lawsuit.”

Thomson says that’s not the point.

“This is not a free speech issue,” she says. “This is a false speech issue. If you are going to allege false facts, that’s not protected by our Constitution. It has become too easy for people to do this online. It’s damaging to reputations. It’s damaging to business, to my own economics. Having potential clients see this on Avvo, obviously it’s damaging.”

Thomson wasn’t deterred by the July court of appeals decision. She says the decision, rather than being a victory for the online posters, was helpful. It gave her guidance, she says, that enables her to amend her complaint.

So, she’ll keep going.

“I tell my kids — pick and choose your battles,” Thomson says. “It’s really not worth it to fuss and fight over every little thing. By having that kind of attitude, you’re going to add a lot more stress to your life. But this is one of those important cases that I’m going to continue to pursue. I want it rectified. I want it remedied. Whatever avenue I have to go, I’m going to continue to go.”

Tags: Politics & Law, Of Counsel

Florida Business News

  • Florida’s population boom drives bigger hurricane losses, despite tougher building codes

    Florida leads the nation in strict building codes, and the decades of hard work have paid off in the increasing number of homes and buildings that survive each time a hurricane slashes the state. But all those hard-won gains have been undermined by the explosion of growth along the coast.

  • Business BeatBusiness Beat - Week of September 29th

    Get top news-to-know with Florida Trend's headline-focused video news brief, hosted by digital content specialist Aimée Alexander.

  • Enterprise Florida exiting

    The doors are ready to close on Enterprise Florida, the business-recruitment agency long targeted by state House leaders.

  • Seeking protection

    Three activist groups served notice to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service that they intend to sue to force the agency to invoke Endangered Species Act protection for the ghost orchid.

  • State jobless claims decrease

    An estimated 5,155 first-time jobless claims were filed in Florida last week, a decrease from the previous week and below the average for the year.

Florida News Releases

Florida Trend Video Pick

Radioactive roads? Florida has yet to submit application to EPA to start testing
Radioactive roads? Florida has yet to submit application to EPA to start testing

It appears no steps have been taken to begin testing whether slightly radioactive waste from fertilizer production can be repurposed for Florida road construction projects.

Video Picks | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

Do you believe that home values in Florida have finally peaked?

  • Absolutely!
  • No way!
  • The jury's still out...
  • Other (Let us know in the comment section below)

See Results

Florida Trend Media Company
490 1st Ave S
St Petersburg, FL 33701
727.821.5800

© Copyright 2023 Trend Magazines Inc. All rights reserved.